After losing to The Bodydonnas in the finals of the World Tag Team Championship tournament during the Free For All before WrestleMania XII, The Godwinns stayed hot on the trail of the new champions in their quest for gold. Their goal was finally realized at an non-televised live event at Madison Square Garden when The Godwinns won the titles using their patented Slop Drop. The Godwinns’ first title reign, would only last one week, though.